Published facts go in. A formula turns them into a number. Nobody invents the total by hand. What you see is 0 to 100.
We read the movement: how it is built, how it beats, how it is tested, what work it actually does. That is 35 points.
We read timekeeping proof. That is 15 points.
We read the case, the seal, the clasp, the crystal and the dial. Case is 20. How you wear and use it is 15. Crystal and dial are 15.
Craft, when it is real, is named beside the total. Mission fit names the job. Vision, on current sheets, is not scored. None of the three is added. A note on parts and service sits beside the sheet. It is not a score.
Price stays off. Brand fame stays off. Auction results stay off. Scarcity stays off. Celebrity stays off. Quartz is not eligible. A hybrid movement is not scored as if it were a beating balance. A brand's own long test is not the same as an independent lab. A clasp you can use on the wrist is not the same as an open dive rack.